Alan Lichtenstein, PPSA
November 2026 - Homeless in Berlin
About the Image(s)
It has been a very old custom for beggars and other indigent people to position themselves outside of churches and beg for alms from patrons entering and leaving the church. This custom is continued in the present, and beggars on the steps and doorways of churches are common in Europe. On our recent trip to Berlin, we had the occasion to see one such beggar.
Gear: Olympus EM-10, zuiko 18-180 lens open to 180mm
Data: ISO 850, f 6.3, 1/250 sec.Metering: center-weighted average
White balance: Manual-measured directly but Kelvin temperature not recorded..
EV = -.3
Date: October 21, 2025
12 comments posted
For me this is indeed an interesting photo although it's a pity that the woman on the left we can not see the whole bag. I would have chosen a 16:9 crop to eliminate and cut out the foreground a bit.   Posted: 11/02/2026 06:17:09
Thanks for your. comments. I presented the. image in landscape mode because I captured the image while standing relatively far away, and hand-held, because I didn't want to be too obvious that I was photographing the beggar. I suppose this is an example of street photography, and most good HI images are obtained by street photographers, of which I do not number myself.   Posted: 11/02/2026 07:08:18
Alan, you pretty much answered yourself by your explanation to Christian. Obviously your viewfinder was centered on the beggar and you overlooked the surroundings and of course you wanted not to be noticed using the 180mm focal length. Interesting that the man walking into the church has a cast on his right leg and is on crutches. The image would be more intense cropping the posters on the side and a good amount of the ground in front of the beggar as was suggested. Good image.   Posted: 11/02/2026 07:59:43
Thanks, Isaac. I'm just about to complete the PSA Image Evaluation course, and in trying to look at images of othered through that lens what PSA, as per its course sewer as image evaluation, I see the shortcomings in my own images. This. image has impact only because of the story and emotional response it conveys, but my use of light and the technicals, leaves something to be desired.   Posted: 11/02/2026 12:24:08
Alan, since you are now taking about photography rules to keep or to brake, on this crop we have the rule of thirds nicely shown by the bagger. I also added a little light to the image (I know that you do not PP your images), and I would have included the whole handbag of the lady   Posted: 11/02/2026 16:19:54

Isaac, you're right; I agree.   Posted: 11/02/2026 18:06:36
This is a much better composition, and Alan, I see that you agree with it too.
I would like to make one further suggestion. If you had moved a little towards the left while taking the photograph, the pathways could have acted as leading lines directing the viewer's eye towards the couple. Also, the lady would have been fully included in the frame. I feel that would have resulted in an even stronger composition.   Posted: 11/06/2026 03:34:30
I would like to make one further suggestion. If you had moved a little towards the left while taking the photograph, the pathways could have acted as leading lines directing the viewer's eye towards the couple. Also, the lady would have been fully included in the frame. I feel that would have resulted in an even stronger composition.   Posted: 11/06/2026 03:34:30
Vinaya, you also are correct. After having just about completed, the PSA Image Evaluation course, I see the same things as do you, and you're right also. The problem is that I don't as yet have these criteria in an unconscious understanding the way I do with technical issues, although the technical issues in this image leave something to be desired as well. I captured the image hand-held as our group was on the move and that contributed to the shortcomings. Had I had a better understanding of some of the composition issues, I might have addressed them, but I didn't. Taking an image hand-held is no excuse for not having better composition or technicals, or, in this case, use of light, but it is an explanation.   Posted: 11/06/2026 05:07:51
Hi Alan,
I understand your concern about not wanting to be too noticeable when photographing the beggar. I felt the same way for a long time. In reportage photography, it took me quite a while to learn that in some situations I need to move closer to what I want to photograph instead of staying at a greater distance.
Over time, I found that getting closer often pulls me more into the scene and gives me a stronger sense of connection with what is happening. Of course, it always depends on the person and the circumstances, and sometimes keeping more distance is absolutely the right choice.
In this photograph, I also prefer Isaac's tighter crop. Removing some of the empty pavement and part of the right side helps concentrate attention on the main situation. I also find the man with the crutches interesting, because he adds another human layer to the image without taking attention away from the beggar.   Posted: 11/05/2026 04:35:41
I understand your concern about not wanting to be too noticeable when photographing the beggar. I felt the same way for a long time. In reportage photography, it took me quite a while to learn that in some situations I need to move closer to what I want to photograph instead of staying at a greater distance.
Over time, I found that getting closer often pulls me more into the scene and gives me a stronger sense of connection with what is happening. Of course, it always depends on the person and the circumstances, and sometimes keeping more distance is absolutely the right choice.
In this photograph, I also prefer Isaac's tighter crop. Removing some of the empty pavement and part of the right side helps concentrate attention on the main situation. I also find the man with the crutches interesting, because he adds another human layer to the image without taking attention away from the beggar.   Posted: 11/05/2026 04:35:41
Thanks for your input, Karel.   Posted: 11/05/2026 07:14:49
Alan the pink blanket in the center of the image takes your eye to the point " a woman begging for money" very very common. I think if you could had move a bit closer, and a bit to the right angle to capture the gentleman in a cast it would/could have had a stronger impact... Not sure the foreground (that much of the it) needed to be included ...
The lady's face and the background is very sharp! If your intend was to point out the women uou definitely made your point for centering the lady...   Posted: 11/06/2026 17:37:20
The lady's face and the background is very sharp! If your intend was to point out the women uou definitely made your point for centering the lady...   Posted: 11/06/2026 17:37:20
Thank you.   Posted: 11/06/2026 19:03:38