Carolyn Todd-Larson, PPSA, AFIAP  


Freedom 250 at Grand Teton by Carolyn Todd-Larson, PPSA, AFIAP

November 2026 - Freedom 250 at Grand Teton

November 2026 - Carolyn Todd-Larson, PPSA, AFIAP

Original

About the Image(s)

John and I stopped at a parking area at Grand Teton National Park and there was this frame on an easel with a view of the mountain in the distance. I thought it was odd that the frame wasn’t high enough so that the view wouldn’t include the stone wall. But I took a photo anyhow because our local photo club has a competition on “creative framing” this year. Anyhow, the frame, created by the National Park Service, commemorates America’s 250th birthday, and I think it’s somehow unique. Not sure if it would do well in exhibitions. Tell me what you think.

Camera: SONY ILCE-7M3
Lens: FE 28-70mm F3.5-5.6 OSS
Focal Length: 28 mm
Exposure: 1/30 sec; f/11; ISO 100

Basic Lightroom adjustments; straightening; cropping to bring frame to the edges. Sharpening using Topaz AI.

Original included so you can see the entire setting.


9 comments posted




Alan Lichtenstein   Alan Lichtenstein
(Group 4)
I don't usually intrude in other study groups, but you had asked for comments, so I'll accommodate your request, as I have just completed the PSA Image Evaluation course, and this gives me a chance to somewhat practice what I have learned. Although your presentation is creative, I don't think this image will do well in competition. Landscapes, save those that have some unusual feature in the image, tend to not do well because they lose impact. while your presentation certainly adds to the originality of the image, as one takes a second look at the image and there are few if any of the usual composition effects that add to impact. Similarly, with the art elements. You have an interesting image, and may do well in your club's competition because from what you say, the competition is themed to have the image do well, but in general composition, I don't think so.   Posted: 11/09/2026 06:36:03



Jen Fawkes   Jen Fawkes
(Group 2)
Hi Carolyn, I do agree that this is a very clever idea, and very unique, that the National Parks Service have done by providing framing to a spectacular scene.
I do think that judges might be a bit confused as your cropping is tight enough to suggest this is a picture frame on the wall rather than an insight into what is outside. If this had been taken wider to show what's in the frame AND what's outside so the viewer would understand the meaning of the frame, then the image becomes stronger.
I don't agree with Alan's comments about 'landscapes' not tending to do well. Its a lovely landscape that demonstrates layering (the wall, the middle ground, the mountain), the mountains are quite spectacular with those ominous clouds creating a mood of cold/ bleak weather approaching.
I do think it also meets the requirement of your club theme.   Posted: 11/12/2026 19:03:24



Jen Fawkes   Jen Fawkes
(Group 2)
Hi Carolyn, I do agree that this is a very clever idea, and very unique, that the National Parks Service have done by providing framing to a spectacular scene.
I do think that judges might be a bit confused as your cropping is tight enough to suggest this is a picture frame on the wall rather than an insight into what is outside. If this had been taken wider to show what's in the frame AND what's outside so the viewer would understand the meaning of the frame, then the image becomes stronger.
I don't agree with Alan's comments about 'landscapes' not tending to do well. Its a lovely landscape that demonstrates layering (the wall, the middle ground, the mountain), the mountains are quite spectacular with those ominous clouds creating a mood of cold/ bleak weather approaching.
I do think it also meets the requirement of your club theme.   Posted: 11/12/2026 19:03:24



Leslie Larson   Leslie Larson
(Group 6)
Does need context...just a little of the surroundings would do it...otherwise it looks like you are taking a photo of someone else's picture.   Posted: 11/13/2026 16:13:33



Carolyn Todd-Larson   Carolyn Todd-Larson
I appreciate all your comments on this. Here's a revision I just made. Needs more editing and fine tuning but it's a quick remake.   Posted: 11/13/2026 20:16:23
Comment Image
Jen Fawkes   Jen Fawkes
(Group 2)
Ok i think this now makes an excellent travel image, with a very original perspective that now tells 2 stories - the beautiful landscape and the commemoration.   Posted: 11/14/2026 17:07:13



Tom Tauber   Tom Tauber
Reminds me of the Kodak spots that used to be all the rage before mass photography. The comments by group members are well taken. In a situation like this, it would make the picture more interesting if there was a story to it, perhaps a photographer standing in front of the frame between the frame and you, taking a picture, or something like that.   Posted: 11/16/2026 12:03:44



Pinaki Sarkar   Pinaki Sarkar
I really appreciate the composition framed by the viewing window. It has strong layering and depth, which are key elements of a classic landscape photograph. In fact, if you photographed the landscape itself using this composition, it would be a very strong image from a theoretical and compositional standpoint.

To convey the interesting concept behind the scene, I would definitely include the viewing stand in the photograph as well, just as you did in the discussion. Doing so adds context and creates a much more clever, unique, and memorable travel photograph. The frame becomes part of the story rather than just a way of presenting the view.   Posted: 11/17/2026 13:04:41



John Larson   John Larson
I agree that your first submission looks like you framed someone else's image. Your second submission is much more suitable as a photo travel image. Something in the photo to serve as a center of interest would add impact. To counteract the placement of the "frame" one could get down on their knees and shoot up at the mountains which would allow more sky to show in the image.   Posted: 11/17/2026 13:20:27



 

Please log in to post a comment