Laurie Bergner  


Cremation in Varanasi.  by Laurie Bergner

April 2024 - Cremation in Varanasi.

About the Image(s)

Canon camera: ISO 400, 12mm, f/2.8, 1/640 sec

Varanasi, one of the oldest continuously inhabited cities in the world, is situated on the River Ganges, the holiest river in India. It is believed that if you die in Varanasi, you end the cycle of reincarnation and achieve moksha, or release from reincarnation. After a person dies, their body is washed by their family. Then the men carry the body to one of the burning ghats. When you visit Varanasi, you can sometimes see bodies being carried to the river, where they will be washed. Then they place the body on a funeral pyre to be cremated by the river. After cremation, the ashes are spread in the river. While there is one ghat where most of the cremations are done, I came upon this smaller one when I was walking along the river further from the main one. There it was, right in front of me. It's an amazing experience to have death be so much a part of life, not hidden as it is in Western countries. In this photo, you can see the men carrying the body, and you can also see burning funeral pyres by the water.


This round’s discussion is now closed!
8 comments posted




Jason Poblete
What a fascinating photo! The people are almost casual about what is taking place and doing it out in the open for the world to see; quite a different approach to death rituals than I am used to. It is the sort of place I would've made the effort to go real up close, and snapped a few closer to the pyre. The contrast of fire and water, the casual manner in which these folks are going about seems a bit irreverent but I guess I'd need to be there to soak it all in. Can't help but also think of the different scents   Posted: 04/10/2024 20:08:11



Judith Ponti-Sgargi   Judith Ponti-Sgargi
Laurie

With my cultural background, it was an experience visiting the ghat in the early morning watching the rising sun as the bodies were cremated on the ghat.

I see the story has carrying the man to the funeral pyre. I find my eye carried out of the image by the upward right diagonal cement. I think the story might be stronger by removing the distraction of the wall, straightening it, and adding more color contrast which would draw the eye to the orange robes and fire, thus connecting the two areas. Straightening the image leads to a tighter crop which would still include the sacred river. You could even crop more from the top than I have suggested in the attached.   Posted: 04/11/2024 06:26:14
Comment Image
Laurie Bergner
Thanks - very good suggestions!   Posted: 04/11/2024 07:40:05



Carolyn Todd-Larson   Carolyn Todd-Larson
Very intriguing photo and there definitely is a compelling story here but the first thing I noticed after the men carrying the body was the slant of the river. The boats appear to be going uphill. Judith has the right idea of straightening. I think you should keep the boats in the shot.   Posted: 04/14/2024 12:52:39



Birgit Langmann   Birgit Langmann
I like this rendition of death, though after the body leaves the hospital floor, I am ignorant of what happens. Each state has rules on how to handle human remains. Not sure how sanitary it is to have that many ashes in the river are.

Photographically, it is difficult to differentiate between smoke and cloudy-foggy day. Could be there is enough smoke in the air to make it look gray-ish. While part of me wants to see the men's expression, the photographer in me says that would be an invasion in privacy.

Not sure what the boats in the river means...is that where they take the ashes to be washed away?

  Posted: 04/21/2024 10:35:24



Laurie Bergner
The bodies are taken straight from the hospital to the funeral pyrez, where they are cremated immediately, surrounded by family. And the ashes are spread in the river Ganges, which is considered holy. This did not feel like an invasion of privacy because all of this is done in a very public place and people are going back-and-forth all the time. I did not sense any hostility from them.   Posted: 04/21/2024 10:53:34
Comment Image
Laurie Bergner
  Posted: 04/21/2024 10:54:00
Comment Image



Laurie Bergner
I would welcome feedback on whether these two images are stronger for the story. Or maybe they all work together?   Posted: 04/21/2024 10:54:42