Arunanjan Saha  


Praying it Through by Arunanjan Saha

April 2024 - Praying it Through

About the Image(s)

This image was taken at the Dhankar (meaning goes as fort by the cliff) Gompa in Spiti valley. It was a late winter afternoon, around -11*C with wind typical of this region of the himalayas. The complex is built on a 300 metre high spur overlooking the confluence of the Spiti and Pin Rivers and it dates back to 12th century. In the image the Buddhist monk (lama) is seen standing on the highest roof of the Gompa (monastery). He is holding a jaapmala in his hands which implies he was praying at that time. He stands facing the ice-capped peaks of himgiri, the confluence is at the foothills which can be seen from where the monk was standing. I got the image from a level down from that monk as one can see. For me this moment was a conjecture of old traditions, our trail as a civilisation and the challenges we face. The peaks that once were ice clad for almost 6 months a year, are now scarcely iceclad when the winter is not even over in that region. The two rivers which were visible to the monk share same fate as the mountain peaks overlooking them. Global warming has overwhelmed us with its multifaceted expressions and impacts. The modern world, far from Dhankar, is trying to make a defence against Global warming. We are arguing, protesting and discussing so as to find our way forward with our science and tech advancements. And then there are these people, who are standing face to face with mother nature armed with faith and prayers in the remotest regions of our planet.

Date: 1st April, 2023
Gear and settings: Nikon Z6ii, Nikkor 24-120 f4 @24mm, 1/2500 s, f4, 100 iso, Handheld
Post processing: Adobe lightroom


This round’s discussion is now closed!
6 comments posted




Ron Davis   Ron Davis
Hi Arunanjan. This photo to me is about hanging flags on a roof with a mountain back drop covered with snow at the peak and about 70% of the photo showing sky. The man has his back to the camera and gives no indication to who he is or his status. The story you tell is very interesting but I don't think the photo explains this.   Posted: 04/07/2024 01:06:33
Arunanjan Saha   Arunanjan Saha
Hi Ron, thanks for the comment. I agree with you that this photograph has strong elements like hanging flag, snow peaks and the sky. Also I never wanted to 'explain' global warming through this photo. This is my first submission and all I wanted was share the process that went in my head. Photographs are blessed with projections and that is what makes it more interesting.

I do feel differently about your take on the man standing. A buddhist monk is well identifiable by attire and also when they have the jaapmala in their hands that implies they are praying.

It was nice to receive your comment on my submission.   Posted: 04/07/2024 07:06:48
Ron Davis   Ron Davis
Hi Arunanjan. Sorry for the incorrect interpretation on how a monk dresses I am familiar with them wearing red robes and shaven heads, obviously I have a limited or narrow understanding. An old photographic judge said to me photos are all about proportions, if you photograph a landscape with about 70 % sky it is not a landscape it is a sky photo, if you photograph a landscape and people are throughout the photo then it is PJ. You have to get the percentages right.   Posted: 04/09/2024 02:22:28
Arunanjan Saha   Arunanjan Saha
Thanks again Ron! I loved how constructive and helpful your feedback is. I'll definitely try to get the percentages in the ball park next time. I do hope that I'll improve in my next submission.   Posted: 04/09/2024 02:38:21



Jen Fawkes   Jen Fawkes
Hi Arunanjan, just to explain to you about Human Interest. The PJ definition for Human Interest is that the image must meet all of the general PJ requirements and also must contain a person/s in an interactive, unusual or emotional situation. This suggests that the story in the image should be about the person rather than the environment or activity they are engaged in. So your image would meet the core requirements, but as a HI image, the story about the monk is a weak one since we cannot see his face, and we are not clear about what he is doing. Technically I can't fault your choices, but I might suggest you get up a little closer so that we are not peeping over the edge of the building which blocks some of the story.   Posted: 04/09/2024 04:07:37



Leslie Larson   Leslie Larson
Good travel photo, but not an HI one. The person is nearly irrelevant.   Posted: 04/09/2024 10:16:54